Simultaneous Elections in India: A Proposal for Electoral Reform
Description
Simultaneous Elections in India: A Proposal for Electoral Reform
Introduction
In India, the debate over simultaneous elections, where both parliamentary and state assembly elections are held together, has gained significant traction in recent years.
The idea of simultaneous elections is not new to India. In fact, until 1967, Lok Sabha (parliamentary) elections and state assembly elections were often held concurrently. However, owing to various factors such as political exigencies, regional dynamics, and logistical challenges, this practice gradually faded away, leading to the current scenario of staggered elections at different levels of government.
Recently, The High-Level Committee (Chair: Former President Mr Ram Nath Kovind) constituted by the central government submitted its report on simultaneous elections.
Key observations and recommendations of the Committee include:
Rationale for simultaneous election:
The Committee recommended simultaneous elections to ensure stability and predictability in governance.
Frequent elections create uncertainty and disrupt policy continuity.
Simultaneous elections reduce costs and increase voter participation.
Research suggests they lead to higher economic growth, lower inflation, increased investments, and improved quality of government expenditure.
Implementation of simultaneous election:
Constitutional amendments are necessary for the framework proposed by the Committee.
All state assemblies and local bodies should be dissolved at the time of the next Lok Sabha election.
Elections for Lok Sabha, state assemblies, and local bodies should be held simultaneously, with local body elections within 100 days.
Term synchronization:
To address the issue of unsynchronized terms due to hung legislatures, fresh elections for such bodies should be held for a reduced term.
The reduced term should align with the remaining period of the five-year cycle for simultaneous elections.
Need for ratification by states:
Constitutional amendments related to Parliament and state assemblies do not require ratification by states.
However, amendments related to local bodies require ratification by at least half of the states.
Single electoral roll:
The Committee suggests adopting a single electoral roll to reduce redundancy and duplication.
The Election Commission of India (ECI) should prepare this roll in consultation with State Election Commissions (SECs).
Constitutional amendments and ratification by at least half of the states are required for this change.
Logistical requirements:
The Election Commission of India (ECI) and State Election Commissions (SECs) should plan and estimate logistical arrangements around the time of implementation.
Advantages of Simultaneous Elections
Cost Efficiency: Conducting elections involves significant financial resources. Simultaneous elections could lead to substantial cost savings by consolidating logistical arrangements, security deployment, and other administrative expenses.
Administrative Ease: Coordinating multiple rounds of elections across the country poses logistical challenges for election authorities. Simultaneous elections could streamline the electoral process, reducing administrative burden and enhancing efficiency.
Political Stability: Frequent elections can disrupt governance and policy continuity. Simultaneous elections may provide a more stable political environment, allowing elected representatives to focus on governance rather than perpetual campaigning.
Enhanced Voter Turnout: With simultaneous elections, voters may be more inclined to participate as they are not inundated with frequent electoral cycles. This could potentially lead to higher voter turnout and greater engagement in the democratic process.
Challenges and Concerns
Constitutional Amendments: Implementing simultaneous elections would require substantial amendments to the Indian Constitution, particularly regarding the tenure of state assemblies and the synchronization of their terms with the Lok Sabha.
Federalism and Regional Diversity: India is a diverse country with distinct regional political dynamics. Critics argue that imposing simultaneous elections could undermine the autonomy of states and dilute regional voices in the democratic process.
Logistical Challenges: Coordinating elections across the vast and diverse landscape of India presents formidable logistical challenges, including security arrangements, polling station management, and voter education campaigns.
Political Opposition: The proposal for simultaneous elections has faced resistance from several political parties, citing concerns about its potential to favor national parties over regional ones and its impact on the democratic fabric of the country.
How to Prepare for IAS | FAQs on UPSC | Up-to-date Current Affairs | Latest Videos & Updates | Article: Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail
